HomeOpinionCritical Reflection on the “Alliance for Survival” 

Critical Reflection on the “Alliance for Survival” 

Alliance for Survival _ Ethiopia
File Photo

By  Assefa Negash, M.D.
Amsterdam, the Netherlands 

The Italian Colonial Origins of the “Artificial Empire” Thesis

Italian scholars such as Carlo Conti Rossini and Enrico Cerulli laid the intellectual groundwork for Italy’s invasion of Ethiopia by spreading their colonialist perspective regarding the people and state of Ethiopia. These two scholars were primarily the main personalities who visited the country before the fascist invasion of Ethiopia in October 1935 and produced work that facilitated the Italian invasion and the subsequent policies that were adapted by the fascist rulers of Ethiopia. They propagated the thesis that Ethiopia is not a historic, unified nation-state, but rather an “artificial empire” or “museum of peoples – something that was subsequently adopted by the radical Ethiopian student movement, the Ethiopian left and various ethno-nationalist movements that took up arms to destroy the oppressive “colonial empire” forcibly held together by the Amharas. The ethno-nationalist forces finally succeeded in destroying the Ethiopian state in May 1991 and ushered in a new era of fascist rule premised on Tigrean and Oromo ultra-nationalism that has reigned supreme during the last 35 years. 

As early as 1928, Conti Rossini published his book entitled “Storia d’Etiopia” (which translates in English to History of Ethiopia) in which he asserted that Ethiopia is a museum of peoples. Based on this colonial thesis Conti Rossini published in this book and similar works of other Italian orientalists, the Italian fascists justified their brutal invasion of Ethiopia. The Italian fascists framed their invasion of Ethiopia as the “liberation of the oppressed ethnic groups of Ethiopia” from their Amhara oppressors. So this colonial thesis justified the brutal Italian fascist foray into Ethiopia in 1935 in order to liberate the oppressed non-Amhara ethnic groups of Ethiopia from their Amhara curators. According to this Italian colonial narrative, a minority “Semitic” Abyssinian/Amhara ruling class violently subjugated a “Cushitic” majority. We know now how similar definitions created by the Belgian colonial authorities undergirded the gruesome Rwandan genocide of 1994. 

By reducing centuries of intermingling and shared state-building to a binary of Amhara oppressors versus oppressed minorities, the colonial script sought to deliberately deconstruct the Ethiopian identity. 50 years after the liberation of Ethiopia, a home-grown fascist force, which has the overwhelming support of the Tigrean people, seized power in Addis Ababa in May 1991 and claimed that it has come to liberate the oppressed nations, nationalities and peoples of Ethiopia from the yoke of an oppressive Amhara rule. By so doing TPLF equated the military dictatorship of the Dergue with Amhara rule.  In the month of July 1991, during five consecutive days, we witnessed how opportunistic elites of various ethnic groups of Ethiopia who enthusiastically accompanied the TPLF were gleefully welcoming the TPLF at the July 1, 1991 “Peace Conference”. These opportunistic ethnic elites, who claimed to represent Ethiopia’s various ethnic groups, vied to outdo each other in denouncing the “Amhara oppressors,” from whose shackles the TPLF had ostensibly delivered them. I vividly remember the face of the Tigrean leader Meles Zenawi beaming with joy while listening to the various opportunistic elites he selectively gathered at this conference denouncing the previous “Amhara regimes” which were held responsible for the alleged crime they perpetrated on non-Amhara ethnic groups.  

Internalization of Colonialist Concepts About Ethiopia by Ethiopian Left Radicals and Ethnonationalist Liberation Fronts

Decades later, this Italian colonial framework was revived and draped in Marxist terminology by radical Ethiopian student movements in the 1960s. Driven largely by Eritrean, Tigrayan, and Oromo nationalist who masqueraded as Marxist-Leninists, echoed by naive and ill-informed Amhara radicals such as Wallelign Mekonnen—the student movement regurgitated the colonial thesis. This colonialist thesis that was initially created by the Italian colonial scholars framed the Amharas as internal colonizers (Neftegnas) – something that was later adopted by the ethno-nationalist movements running the whole gamut from Eritrea to Tigrai, Oromo, etc. Personally, I for one, do not consider Wallelign Mekonnen as a malicious person who was out to harm the Amharas as people. He was victim of miseducation which our generation shared widely. Of course, I am not trying to absolve those ethno-nationalists within the ranks of the Ethiopian student movement who had strong antipathy, if you like, visceral hatred for the Amhara people, culture, etc as events of the last 35 years have amply taught us. These ethno-nationalists (Eritreans, Tigreans and Oromos, etc) used Marxism skilfully as a garb to hide or cover up their real face. For the Eritrean, Tigrean and Oromo ethno-nationalists, the Ethiopian state led by emperor Menelik, Haile Selassie’s and even  Dergue represented oppressive colonial states that had to be destroyed. Unlike their Eritrean, Tigrean and Oromo elites, the Amhara elites were not bent on the destruction of the Ethiopian state but they sought to democratize the Ethiopian state. It is only lately that some of the Amharas realized how they were duped and cheated by these Eritrean, Tigrean and Oromo ethno-nationalists. These ethno-nationalists used to shout radical slogans on the podiums of Haile Selassie university in the sixties and early 70’s by flaunting high sounding Marxist-Leninist slogans such as “workers of the world unite”. Anyone conversant with the colonialist literature produced by Italian orientalist scholars, pro-fascist individuals like Baron Prochazka does not fail to realize how ill-informed, miss-educated left radicals such as Wallelign and former foot-soldiers of EPRP like myself, who were wet behind ears, echoed the concepts elaborated about Ethiopia by these Italian colonialist scholars and fascist apologists like “Baron Prochazka uncritically.  

When ethno-nationalist fronts like the EPLF, TPLF, and OLF emerged, they adopted this colonial anthropology as their foundational political doctrine. Decades later this  thesis propagated by Italian colonial scholars was subsequently echoed by the likes of Bereketeab Habte Selassie in the following manner:  “Ethiopia is a colonial empire. Its expansion under Menelik II at the end of the nineteenth century was a part of the general scramble for Africa, with the difference that the colonizer was an African power”. Bereket is a man beholden to the colonial legacy of his Italian colonialist masters who enslaved his people and moulded the very thought process of Eritrean nationalists like him. So it is not surprising that Berketeab, like all Eritrean nationalists, harbours visceral hatred towards Ethiopia. Eritrean, Tigrean and Oromo ethno-nationalist and the liberation fronts they created adopted this 1928 colonial framework created by Italians colonialist scholars to deconstruct the Ethiopian state and replace it with Bantustanized ethnic enclaves they created in Ethiopia since June 1991 (the Killil system of territorialization).

On the basis of this colonial anthropology that denied the very concept of an Ethiopian citizen, the Ethiopian map was reconfigured on ethnic identity (blood lines) thereby creating deadly boundaries that precipitated the genocidal mass killings, displacement, etc we have witnessed during the last 35 years. The genocide unfolding in Wellega, Arsi, Gurage, Benishangul, Metekel, Moyale, etc derives from this this territorial reconfiguration of Ethiopia on blood lines. This map almost exactly mirrored the administrative divisions imposed by fascist Italy during its 1935–1941 occupation of Ethiopia.

Upon seizing power in Addis Ababa in May 1991, the TPLF and its allies (EPLF and OLF) immediately disbanded the national army. I want to remind readers that after the Italian fascists, it was the home-grown Tigrean fascist regime led by the TPLF that dismantled the Ethiopian national army – something which only an occupation colonial or fascist army is capable of doing to the national army of an alien country. The TPLF regime had thrown half a million soldiers and their dependants which number at least 1,5 million Ethiopians out on the street thereby exposing them to untold suffering (vagrancy, prostitution, beggary, diseases, penury, hopelessness, etc). 

Codification of “Blood and Soil” in the 1995 Constitution

By adopting the colonial thesis that Ethiopia was merely a “prison of nations” allegedly held together forcibly by Amharas, the TPLF and OLF justified the deconstruction of the Ethiopian state. They replaced it with an ethnic-based federation that institutionalized the German Nazi concept of “Blut und Boden” that translates into Blood and Soil in English through the 1995 Constitution. This announcement of this constitution whose was enthusiastically welcomed by 16 Western government representatives based in Addis Ababa. The 1995 constitution transformed administrative geography into ethno-national property through three key mechanisms which I present here after:

Article 8:  De-centering the Citizen 

The TPLF and OLF are the architects and defenders of the 1995 Constitution. The main content of what was later to morph into the 1995 Ethiopian constitution was drafted and agreed upon by these two groups along with the EPLF at a meeting the trio held in the Eritrean town of Senafe in June 1991. A month after the meeting of the trio at Senafe, this document was adopted as the transitional charter at the July 1, 1991 so-called peace conference held in Addis Ababa. The participation of political groups such as the Ethiopian Democratic Coalition for Democracy (CODEF) that did not toe the ethnically-informed political line of the TPLF was blocked by the TPLF. The Amhara people had no representation at this conference. 

Article 8: Sovereignty of the People

  1. “All sovereign power resides in the Nations, Nationalities and Peoples of Ethiopia”. 

Article 8 of the 1995 Ethiopian Constitution profoundly territorializes identity and sovereignty, though its full territorial mechanism operates in synergy with Article 47.  Through article 8 the constitution ties sovereignty to ethnic identity (descent based on blood lines).  And through article 47, the constitution limits the right of an Ethiopian to a fixed geographical territory or Killil (soil) designated as the exclusive property of one particular ethnic group. As such this constitution institutionalizes the fascist concept of “Blood and Soil” by linking ethnic identity and belonging to descent (blood) and territory (soil). This dangerous article bestows sovereign right on imagined “nations, nationalities and peoples” instead of individual Ethiopian citizens. Based on this article, authority and sovereignty are, henceforth, vested not in a unified “We the People” but in corporately  imagined “Nations, Nationalities and Peoples” who mediate all political power through ancestral bloodlines. Being a constitution which is based on the fascist/Nazi concept of “Blood and Soil”, this constitution strips individuals of universal citizenship, rendering millions of Ethiopians living outside their designated ethnic regions (Killil) as rightless “aliens” or “settlers” that are henceforth seen as anomalous and unwelcome guests or intruders. It is by virtue of this article, that the current Ethiopian constitution renders the very notion of individual Ethiopian citizenship right null and void. 

The Amhara people being the largest group that find themselves dispersed in every nook and cranny of Ethiopia, have become the primary and the most conspicuous victims of genocidal ethnic cleansing that derives from the exclusionary Article 8 and Article 47 of the constitution than anyone other ethnic group of Ethiopia. The gruesome and horrendously violent genocidal ethnic cleansing of hundreds of thousands of Amharas from what is now dubbed Oromia, Benishangul, southern region (Gura Ferda, Sidama), etc is a consequence of this fascistic constitutional arrangement. In 2012 alone, on the order of the leader of the Tigrean fascist regime Meles Zenawi, more than seventy thousands (70000) of Amharas had been ethnically cleansed from Gura Ferda. This fascistic measure was carried out by Shifferaw Shigute, an ultra-nationalist governor of the region that  originally hails from Sidama. Shifferaw Shigute executed this ethnic cleansing project on the order of Meles Zenawi thereby proving his mettle as the minion of this fascistic Tigrean leader.  

Article 47 and the Exclusive Ethnic Territories It Created 

The constitution assigns specific geographic homelands (Regions or Killils as they are known in Amharic) to designated titular ethnic groups. This fuses sovereignty with exclusive territory thereby treating land as an ethnic asset. Consequently, non-titular citizens (such as for example the Amharas living in Oromia, Benishangul-Gumuz, or Somali regions) are structurally disenfranchised and treated as alien settlers stripped of genuine local representation. The case of Harar city where a significant percentage of the population that are represented by Amharas with zero percent representation illustrates the glaring contradiction of the current fascist constitution of Ethiopia. 

Article 39 and the Right to Secession: 

By granting ethnic units an unconditional right to self-determination and secession, the constitution frames Ethiopia not as an organic historic nation, but as a temporary, contractual federation of distinct sovereign ethnic republics that can opt out of the ethnic federal arrangement at will. Ultimately, this constitutional architecture legally abrogates universal Ethiopian citizenship. It ensures that political rights, sovereignty, and belonging are determined strictly by ancestral descent tied to demarcated ethnic group (blood) and ethnically designated area (soil). It is this fascist or Nazi constitutional arrangement that undergirds the two genocidal regimes (TPLF and the incumbent Orommuma) in power during the last 35 years.  

Cartographic Continuity from Fascist Italian Period (1945-1941)

The ethnic regional (Kilil) map created by the TPLF and OLF in 1991 directly mirrors the 1935–1941 map of Ethiopia created by Italian fascists. This ethno-linguistic division has been implemented by the TPLF to prevent a unified pan-Ethiopian resistance. This redrawal of the Ethiopian map allowed the TPLF to annex the fertile lands of Welkait and Raya while the OLF annexed vast territories historically inhabited by the Amhara people (northern Shewa) and parts of Ethiopia historically inhabited by people of southern Ethiopia, Ethiopian Somalis (as witness the current expansionist incursion and forays into the Somali inhabited regions of Moyale and the Ogaden).  

The “Unholy Alliance” and the Irreconcilable Political Goals 

The recent coalition between the Amhara Fano movement, the TPLF, and the OLA, etc is deeply contradictory because the foundational doctrines and ultimate goals of groups like OLF and TPLF on the one hand and the FANO movement on the other, are at loggerheads with each other. The political goals of these two groups are irreconcilable to say the least. In fact ideologically, the OLF/TPLF duo share everything with the incumbent fascist regime led by Abiy Ahmed. Their difference relates to the issue of who should control power!!!

Both TPLF & OLF/OLA are organizations who base their ideology on the Italian colonial narrative that Ethiopia is an empire built on Amhara oppression of non-Amhara ethnic groups of Ethiopia. Their ultimate goal is the disintegration of Ethiopia to form independent states (Oromia and Tigrai). The creation of an independent Tigrai has become paramount for TPLF after it was ousted from power in 2018. For the TPLF, an independent Tigray cannot be realised without annexing  the fertile lands of Welkait and Tsegede which account for 45% of agricultural production of Tigrai according to the pronouncement of a former Tïgrean official who was head of the agricultural bureau of the Tigrai regional state. 

The Amhara Fano emerged specifically to protect Amharas from the genocide, displacement, and structural disenfranchisement caused by the TPLF/OLF following the ethno-federal system that these two ultra-nationalist groups created in 1991. Fano is bent on changing this political system that generates all these problems. TPLF and OLF are committed to the continuation of this discriminatory and genocidal constitutional order at all cost. Fano on the other hand seeks to preserve the Ethiopian state, dismantle the current fascist regime based on the Nazi ideology of blood and soil and democratize the Ethiopian state by guaranteeing the individual rights of everyone Ethiopian citizen without any consideration of descent (blood tie) or soil (regional origin) as criteria of belonging. 

The Strategic Danger for Fano 

Because the TPLF and OLF are fully committed to maintaining this exclusionary ethno-regional arrangement, Fano’s alignment with them risks legitimizing the very fascist political system it seeks to undo. FANO’s decision to join this alliance is short-sighted and compromises completely the very raison d’être of this popular grassroot Amhara movement. It is purely an opportunistic, transactional pact that will inevitably collapse into structural enmity once their common rival falls. History does not provide us even with one single example of fascist political groups such as the TPLF and OLF that have kept their words and adhered to agreements they have entered into with other groups. Both the TPLF and the OLF/OLA being ultra-nationalist fascist forces, are adept at changing their colour like chameleon in duping and later dumping their enemies once they have achieved their goal. The Molotov-Ribbentrop non-aggression pact of August 23, 1939 signed between Hitler and the Soviet Union that was later broken by Hiter when he invaded the Soviet Union is a clear example of how fascists easily discard pacts, agreements, etc they signed to lure their enemies into a trap. It is not surprising that many Amharas rightly feel that their political cause has been sold out by gullible, ill-informed and selfish FANO leaders who do not measure up to the tasks, responsibilities and daunting existential challenges being faced by the Amhara people. 

It is the responsibility of every FANO supporter to oppose this dangerous political course of selling out the very cardinal cause of the FANO movement by sanitizing two fascist forces i.e. OLF and TPLF, whose ideology and memory should be buried once and for all like their Nazi and fascist predecessors of Germany and Italy respectively. Particularly, some FANO leaders’ effort to rescue and resuscitate the TPLF which has begun to die a natural death within its own turf of Tigrai and has left behind a trail of death and destruction on the Amhara people during the recent war (2020-2022) is mind boggling to say the least. Not surprisingly, the arch enemy of Ethiopia, Eritrea happens to be the main actor that is orchestrating this unholy alliance from behind while historically hostile countries such as Egypt and the Sudan are standing behind Eritrea. 

Since its creation as a separate colonial turf of the Italians in 1890, Eritrea has continued to pose danger to Ethiopia as witness the collaboration of the people of this former Italian colony alongside Italian colonialists both in 1896 and during the 1935 fascist Italy’s invasion of Ethiopia. According to an Eritrean nationalist Woldeyesus Ammar, during the Adwa war, over 8000 Eritrean askaris (bandas) participated in the war against Ethiopians while during the 1935 invasion of Ethiopia by fascist Italy, 75000 Eritrean askaris fought against Ethiopians by allying with their Italian masters. The incumbent Eritrean regime, which is nervous about the emergence of any independent Ethiopian political group that does not kow-tow to the whims of Eritrea, has succeeded in infiltrating the ranks of the Fano leadership. This it has done by proxy through the work of two of its paid agents Andargatchew Tsige (based in London) and Mohammed Hassan (based in Belgium). These two individuals shuttle between Europe, Eritrea, Sudan and Kenya, etc to carry out the subversive plans of the dictatorial Eritrean regime. These two people are individuals of dubious character who served the TPLF as former cadres in the first years of TPLF’s rule. They are individuals who lead uneventful and inconsequential lives in London and Belgium respectively. Being individuals who lead meaningless lives in Europe, they have no qualms about promoting the deconstructionist agenda of the EPLF in Ethiopia as long as they are paid for their mercenary services. They feel no moral compunction about subverting an otherwise genuine political movement—Fano—by turning it into an appendage of the Eritrean regime. To achieve this, they rely on gullible and pliant individuals like Zemene Kassie, with whom they have built a close relationship while he was serving as a Ginbot 7 cadre in Eritrea. Sadly, self-styled journalists of Anchor Media, Addis Dimtse and Zewdu Show – have been giving wide coverage to Mohammed Hassan – a mercenary individual who unabashedly praises and panegyrizes the criminal Eritrean regime and presents himself as an expert analyst through these channels courtesy of these self-styled journalists who do not even dare to challenge his brazen lies. Mohammed Hassan and Andargatchew Tsige are engaged in the unconscionable acts of promoting the political project of the Eritrean regime that is bent on dividing Ethiopia along ethnic lines by working in cahoots with Egypt – a country with a long history of enmity towards Ethiopia owing to the issue of the Blue Nile river. 

In order to bring down the incumbent fascist Oromumma regime led by Abiy Ahmed, Fano has to get rid of those individuals within its leadership who have compromised and sold out its cause by being an instrument of the inimical Eritrean/Egyptian political project. Fano should pull out from this unholy alliance it forged with TPLF and OLF/OLA. Instead it should work towards the creation a broad anti-fascist front that replaces the incumbent fascist political order that has landed Ethiopia into a place where carnage, displacement and untold suffering have become recurring phenomena during the last 35 years. Fano can create such an alliance by enlisting the support of the people of southern Ethiopia, Gambella, Benishangul, Somali, Afar, etc  whose existence is threatened by the incumbent Orommuma regime that is making violent forays into their territories by carrying out ethnic cleansing, causing massive  displacement, enforcing forced assimilation, etc owing to the expansionist, war-like and violent nature of the very fascist ideology that guides this regime. Fano can also count on the majority of the urban population of Ethiopia who are suffering under the fascistic rule of the Orommuma regime. It does not behove or befit Fano to look up to the dictatorial regime of Eritrea which has historically been anathema to the unity and welfare of Ethiopia neither as a tactical nor as a strategic ally. The incumbent regime shares the same fascist ideology with the OLF/OLA and the TPLF. As such it is pointless for the Fano movement to seek any kind of accommodation both with the TPLF and OLF/OLA. 

Note to readers:

In my paper, I have made reference to two individuals based in Europe who are running errands for the Eritrean regime along with self-styled journalists who promote these two individuals here in the diaspora. If any one of them wants to challenge my claim, I am ready to face them in a public debate. Any one of them who is worth his salt and has the courage of his convictions is welcome to challenge me!!!!  

Readers can reach me via my email address: Debesso@gmail.com 

Editor’s Note: Views in the article do not necessarily reflect the views of borkena.com  

__

Join our Telegram Channel: t.me/borkena

Like borkena on Facebook

To submit a press release, send the submission to info@borkena.com

Add your business to Ethiopian Business Listing / Ethiopian Business Directory  

Join the conversation. Follow us on X (formerly Twitter)  @zborkena to get the latest Ethiopian news updates regularly

advertisment

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here