HomeOpinion    It’s the TPLF, stupid! (Shanko Dache)

    It’s the TPLF, stupid! (Shanko Dache)

Why doubts surround the credibility, goals and intentions of Ethiopia’s new opposition coalition

Debretsion _ TPLF _ Ethiopia
Debretsion Gebremichael (file photo)

By Shanko Dache

Alliances in politics often form for mutual benefit. As a result, political rivals may come together due to having a common enemy. This is certainly true in relation to Ethiopia’s newly formed opposition coalition; the Ethiopian Peoples’ Forces Alliance for Survival. However, the composition of this coalition raises significant questions in regards to its credibility, goals and intentions. “It’s the TPLF, stupid!”

Much like ‘It’s the economy, stupid!’ was a phrase used in Bill Clinton’s 1992 presidential campaign to highlight the main issue in a political debate, a similar phrase could be appropriate in Ethiopia. In the case of Ethiopia, the phrase could be; it’s the TPLF, stupid!

While this is not to suggest that all organizations in this coalition share the same political background and objectives as the TPLF, it is to highlight that in order to understand why many Ethiopians may have skeptical feelings about this new alliance, examining the TPLF’s history is essential.

Significance of TPLF history

The TPLF was extremely dominant within the ruling Ethiopian People’s Revolutionary Democratic Front (EPRDF), and therefore had significant influence over Ethiopia’s political, military, intelligence and economic structures between 1991 and 2018. Within the EPRDF, although it was made up of multiple regional parties, the TPLF exercised significantly extreme influence within the ruling party.

Controversial history

A highly significant decision made by the TPLF-led political regime was the implementation of ethnic federalism. Within this system, as outlined by the 1995 constitution, Ethiopia was divided according to the ethno-linguistic identities of the population. Nations, nationalities and peoples in Ethiopia were granted the right to self-determination, including the right to secede (Article 39).

While this was welcomed by many in recognition of historical marginalization and in order to represent the rich variety of cultures within Ethiopia, it has been heavily criticized. The decision to organize Ethiopia around ethnic identities has led to increased competition between different ethnic groups, reducing collective national identity. It has led to divisions in territory and politics.

While it is extremely important to recognize Ethiopia’s ethnically diverse and culturally diverse population, the question that arises is whether ethnic identities should be the framework of political governance in the country and what rights/opportunities citizens should have as a result.

Another example of controversial political decisions made by the ruling EPRDF government is the suppression of protests in response to the 2005 general elections. Both June and November saw extreme repression by security forces. As reported by Human Rights Watch, demonstrations were brutally crushed, leading to deaths of protestors. There was mass arrest, and the detention of opposition leaders. The government commission found that 193 civilians and six security force members were killed in these violent events. Prominent opposition figures, journalists and civil society members were put on trial and incarcerated. These events in 2005 were significant in shaping the relationship between the ruling regime and opposition in Ethiopia.

Freedom of Independent Journalism

As stated in Human Rights Watch’s 2015 report, Journalism Is Not a Crime, many publications have been closed down in Ethiopia. Journalists had been arrested and jailed. Dozens of Ethiopian journalists had gone into exile. Since 2010, at least 60 journalists had left Ethiopia.  This indicates that significant restrictions had occurred regarding free independent journalism in Ethiopia throughout the latter years of the EPRDF government.

Political system

There had been frequent accusations in relation to the political system. Arbitrary arrests, politically-motivated prosecution, intimidation of opposition members and human rights abuses had all been reported.

Although there was significant economic growth, developments in infrastructure and improvements in certain socio-economic indicators under the TPLF-led government, it is still important to consider questions of political accountability, democratic rights and concentration of power in the country.

The TPLF-led EPRDF regime ended in 2018. Therefore, the TPLF’s return to the center of political decision-making in Ethiopia is unlikely to be viewed by many Ethiopians as an ordinary political development.

Why former opponents are uniting

A particularly notable aspect of this coalition is that it consists of former opposing groups.

The TPLF and Amhara Fano fought on opposite sides in the 2020-22 devastating Tigray war. Despite signing the Pretoria Agreement in November 2022, political and territorial tensions between the two groups continue.

The Oromo Liberation Army has its own history, aims and tensions with the Ethiopian state. The remaining groups also represent unique regional issues and political goals. Despite this, what is uniting these groups?

It appears that a common opposition to the current regime is uniting these groups. However, despite the coalition forming it cannot be assumed that these groups share a common vision for Ethiopia’s future.

Being opposed to the same government does not mean groups share the same vision for how Ethiopia should be governed.

Questions raised by proposed inclusive transition

The creation of an inclusive transitional government raises many questions. Firstly, what type of constitutional system would this be based upon? Secondly, what would happen to ethnic federalism? Thirdly, how would conflicting territorial claims be resolved? Lastly, what assurances would be given to citizens who do not belong to the political groups being represented through these armed movements?

These questions are extremely important in determining whether or not this political alliance is a viable alternative. If these questions go unanswered, it is questionable whether this alliance is a sustainable alternative.

Importance of TPLF in coalition

This coalition contains the TPLF meaning it has significant implications. Within Ethiopia, many people associate the TPLF with the previous ruling party. Therefore, due to the questions that have been raised in relation to its previous rule, its interaction with other political groups, and its approach to governing Ethiopia, public opinion may be influenced.

While it is legitimate for political groups to be part of peaceful political competition, there are concerns in relation to whether this coalition truly represents a change in political practice within Ethiopia.

If this coalition aims to return, directly or indirectly, to the political system in place prior to 2018, it must address the concerns of citizens who were unhappy with this previous arrangement.

However, if it truly aims to create political change in a democratic way, it must be very clear as to how it plans to create a political system that differs from that created and dominated by the TPLF.

Merely declaring democratic intentions is not sufficient. To be seen as credible, this political alliance must have clear goals in relation to political governance, protections, accountability and clear commitment to equal citizenship.

Credibility concerns

A concern facing this coalition is a lack of obvious common political goals. Given that these groups have different political backgrounds, demographics, regional interests and ideologies within them, and that some have been engaged in armed struggle for many years, and others have been in political systems that have put them directly at odds with each other, there is a great deal of disagreement between members of the coalition. In particular, the disputed border land between Amhara and Tigray (especially in Western Tigray) is a large source of political tension.

Although leaders of this coalition may claim that tensions can be resolved through discussion once the current government has been removed, this raises the question of whether, if these groups could not resolve their differences in opposition to the government, there are any guarantees that they will be able to do so once in power.

Ethiopia has previously suffered as a result of political systems claiming to bring change to the country, but failing to create sustainable democratic systems.

Therefore, Ethiopia cannot afford to attempt another political experiment where political groups agree to remove the government but have very different ideas of what kind of state they wish to create.

Removing a government is not the same as saving a country

There are undeniable serious political, economic, security and human rights issues in Ethiopia. The Federal government must be held accountable for the policies it has implemented, the management of armed conflicts, and its responsibility to protect its citizens.

It is legitimate for political groups to be opposed to the government. It is legitimate for people to be critical of Abiy Ahmed’s government. It is legitimate for people to demand political change, accountability, and democratic governance.

However, just because a political alliance opposes the government does not mean that it is a legitimate or credible alternative.

Any political alliance aiming to bring political change within Ethiopia must prove that it represents more than just the combined interests of armed groups. It must have a vision for Ethiopia that includes the diverse population, and does not favor specific ethnicities, regions or political groups.

Most importantly, it must answer the question of what kind of Ethiopia it aims to create.

Will it promote equal citizenship and constitutional democracy? Will it maintain the current ethnic federal system, significantly alter it or completely change it? Will it guarantee political diversity and freedom of speech? Will it accept independent institutions and peaceful transitions of power?

These questions should be clearly answered before asking Ethiopians to trust this political alliance with the future of their country.

Ethiopia needs change, not another monopoly

The political crisis in Ethiopia cannot be solved simply by replacing one set of political elites with another.

Over the last three decades it has been demonstrated that concentrating political power within a single dominant group, or small group of political elites can lead to problematic outcomes. Therefore, it is extremely important to have political institutions to protect all citizens regardless of their ethnicity, political group or region. However,

Although the TPLF, like all political groups, has every right to participate in Ethiopia’s political processes, it would be unreasonable to expect the public to forget its history simply because it has formed an alliance with former adversaries.

Likewise, it would be unreasonable for other groups in the alliance to assume that forming an alliance with the TPLF has no political implications. They must explain how this alliance addresses concerns raised by the TPLF’s previous rule.

Ultimately, the credibility of this alliance will rely on the democratic values, principles and constitutional protections it can provide for Ethiopians, rather than the number of armed groups it includes.

Conclusion

The future of Ethiopia should not simply be defined by a battle over whether Abiy Ahmed should remain or be removed. It is far more important to consider what kind of political system should follow the current regime.

Coalitions aiming to remove the government must demonstrate clear plans on how they will run Ethiopia differently. They must ensure that they will not make the same mistakes as previously, and guarantee equal citizenship within the country. They must ensure peaceful resolution of territorial disputes, and create accountable institutions for all Ethiopians.

Given the TPLF’s involvement in this coalition, these questions are of great significance. It is important to consider the TPLF’s political history in this context.

Ethiopia needs a political movement that can create a country in which no group of people, ethnicity or political elites can claim ownership of the nation.

Therefore, a political movement must be committed to creating a constitutional system that allows equal citizenship, protects individual rights, creates democratic accountability, political diversity and peaceful resolution of political differences. It must also recognize that Ethiopia’s diversity should be seen as a strength, rather than a constant tool for political competition.

Therefore, the alliance should be judged on the democratic values it is willing to support, compromises it is willing to make and constitutional guarantees it can give to all Ethiopians.

That is the real test of this alliance.

And that is why, in understanding the new Ethiopian opposition coalition, the question cannot be avoided:

It’s the TPLF, stupid!

Selected references and further reading

  1. Human Rights Watch, World Report 2006: Ethiopia — documentation of the 2005 post-election violence.
  2. Amnesty International, Ethiopia: 25 Years of Human Rights Violations (2016).
  3. Human Rights Watch, Journalism Is Not a Crime: Violations of Media Freedoms in Ethiopia (2015).
  4. Human Rights Watch, One Hundred Ways of Putting Pressure: Violations of Freedom of Expression and Association in Ethiopia (2010).
  5. Constitution of the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia (1995), particularly Article 39.
  6. U.S. Department of State, 2008 Human Rights Report: Ethiopia.

Editor’s Note: Views in the article do not necessarily reflect the views of borkena.com  

__

Join our Telegram Channel: t.me/borkena

Like borkena on Facebook

To submit a press release, send the submission to info@borkena.com

Add your business to Ethiopian Business Listing / Ethiopian Business Directory  

Join the conversation. Follow us on X (formerly Twitter)  @zborkena to get the latest Ethiopian news updates regularly

advertisment

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here