
Mengistu Musie (Dr.)
Introduction: The Problem of Credibility
From the very beginning of Ethiopia’s National Dialogue Commission, we raised serious concerns about its credibility, independence, and capacity to address the country’s deeply rooted political and historical problems. Our concerns were not simply about establishing another government institution. They were about the fundamental question of whether a commission established and operating under the authority of a government accused of serious human rights violations could genuinely provide an independent platform for national reconciliation.
National dialogue is not an ordinary political exercise. It is a process through which a nation confronts its painful history, acknowledges injustice, recognizes the suffering of its people, and establishes a common foundation for a peaceful political future. It requires courage, honesty, transparency, and, above all, the people’s confidence. Without these conditions, dialogue becomes an administrative exercise rather than a genuine national undertaking.
Ethiopia does not lack political conferences, government committees, constitutional declarations, or promises of reform. What the country lacks is a credible political process that can bring its divided communities together, address historical grievances, establish accountability, and create institutions citizens can trust.
The central question, therefore, is not whether Ethiopia needs national dialogue. It unquestionably does. The question is whether the existing commission possesses the independence, legitimacy, and political environment necessary to accomplish that responsibility.
1. A Commission Cannot Replace the Will of the People
A genuine national dialogue must originate from the people and reflect their collective aspirations. It cannot be designed exclusively by those who hold political power, nor can it be limited to discussions that are acceptable to the government of the day.
The people must have the freedom to determine the issues that deserve attention, identify the historical injustices that require examination, and select representatives who genuinely speak for their communities.
Ethiopia’s political problems did not emerge overnight. They are the consequences of decades of authoritarian government, political exclusion, competing national narratives, ethnic polarization, armed conflict, and institutional failures. These problems cannot be resolved through a commission that merely invites selected individuals to participate in discussions while leaving the underlying political structures untouched.
A credible dialogue must include political organizations, opposition parties, independent intellectuals, civil society institutions, religious leaders, traditional authorities, representatives of displaced populations, victims of political violence, and communities that have experienced marginalization.
More importantly, participation must be voluntary and meaningful. Individuals must be able to speak without fear of intimidation, imprisonment, retaliation, or political consequences.
If participants cannot openly criticize the government, question its policies, or discuss alleged abuses by state institutions. The process cannot reasonably be described as an inclusive national dialogue.
2. The Fundamental Question of Independence
One of our earliest concerns was the institutional relationship between the commission and the government that established it.
There is an important distinction between a commission formally established by a government and one operating independently of government influence. Establishment by the state does not automatically make an institution illegitimate. However, its credibility depends on whether it possesses genuine institutional independence, transparent procedures, adequate resources, and the authority to investigate politically sensitive issues without interference.
This distinction is particularly important in Ethiopia.
The government of Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed has faced serious allegations concerning human rights violations, political repression, displacement, and abuses associated with armed conflicts. These allegations require independent investigation and appropriate legal processes. They cannot simply be dismissed, nor should they be treated as established legal findings without proper examination.
The difficulty arises when the government overseeing a national dialogue is itself among the political actors whose conduct may need to be examined.
How can victims confidently participate in a process when they question whether their experiences will be investigated honestly? How can opposition organizations trust the commission if they believe the government’s political interests influence its mandate, membership, or procedures?
These are not unreasonable questions. They are essential questions that every serious national dialogue must address.
Independence is not something a commission can establish merely by declaring itself independent. It must demonstrate independence through its actions, decisions, and willingness to examine uncomfortable truths.
3. The South African Experience: Lessons from Archbishop Desmond Tutu
The South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission, chaired by Archbishop Desmond Tutu, offers an important historical comparison for Ethiopia.
Following the end of apartheid, South Africa faced an enormous challenge. Its population had experienced decades of institutionalized racial discrimination, political repression, imprisonment, torture, killings, and systematic denial of basic human rights.
The transition from apartheid to democracy did not automatically resolve these historical wounds. The country needed a process through which victims could tell their stories, perpetrators could be confronted, and society could begin addressing the consequences of decades of injustice.
The Truth and Reconciliation Commission was established in 1995 under the Promotion of National Unity and Reconciliation Act. Its work began in 1996. Archbishop Desmond Tutu became its chairperson and played a prominent role in documenting abuses and encouraging national reconciliation.
The South African experience demonstrates that reconciliation cannot be achieved simply by asking people to forget the past. It requires confronting the past.
The commission provided a public platform for victims and witnesses to describe their experiences. It examined violations committed during apartheid and contributed to the country’s historical record. Its work also included examining applications for amnesty under specific legal conditions.
However, the South African experience was not without limitations. Many victims remained dissatisfied with the outcomes; reparations were limited, and questions about accountability continued long after the commission completed its work.
Nevertheless, its historical significance lies in the recognition that a society cannot build a sustainable democratic future by suppressing the truth about its past.
There is an important lesson here for Ethiopia: political reconciliation must be accompanied by truth-seeking, accountability, institutional reform, and recognition of victims.
The South African commission operated during a period when the country was undergoing a difficult political transition. Its existence did not mean that every structure of the previous system had immediately disappeared. Rather, the commission was part of a broader transition toward democratic government.
Ethiopia must understand this distinction. A national dialogue cannot become an instrument for protecting those in power from scrutiny. It must become a means of establishing the truth, including when that truth is politically inconvenient.
4. The Difference Between National Dialogue and Transitional Justice
One of the biggest problems in Ethiopia’s national reconciliation debate is the tendency to treat national dialogue and transitional justice as interchangeable.
They are related, but they are not the same.
National dialogue gives different political and social groups an opportunity to discuss the country’s future, identify areas of disagreement, and negotiate possible political arrangements.
Transitional justice, on the other hand, addresses the consequences of serious violations committed during periods of conflict or authoritarian rule. It includes truth-seeking, accountability, reparations, institutional reform, and guarantees that similar violations will not happen again.
A national dialogue may help establish the political environment necessary for transitional justice. However, it cannot replace independent investigations or judicial accountability.
Consider Ethiopia’s historical experience. The country has experienced political violence under successive governments. The imperial period, the Derg dictatorship, the EPRDF government, and the current political period each require serious historical examination.
The Red Terror, political imprisonment, mass displacement, ethnic violence, and abuses associated with armed conflicts cannot be resolved through general political discussions alone.
Victims deserve more than an opportunity to speak at a conference. They deserve recognition, investigation, and appropriate remedies.
A credible national process must therefore establish a clear relationship between dialogue and transitional justice. Otherwise, reconciliation risks becoming a convenient political language for avoiding responsibility.
5. The Government’s Responsibility and the Problem of Conflicting Interests
A particularly difficult challenge emerges when the government organizing a national dialogue is also accused of committing or enabling violations that the dialogue should address.
This creates a potential conflict of interest.
The purpose of an independent national process should be to investigate historical and contemporary grievances without giving preferential treatment to any political organization, government institution, armed group, or individual.
The government must be willing to accept that its own conduct may become part of the investigation.
This is the test of political accountability.
A government cannot demand public confidence while simultaneously restricting independent political activity, suppressing critical voices, or preventing meaningful investigations into allegations of abuses.
Nor can it expect citizens to trust a process in which the government effectively determines which grievances are legitimate and which are excluded from discussion.
If the commission is to become credible, it must demonstrate that no political institution stands above examination.
The government’s responsibility should be to protect the process, ensure security, respect freedom of expression, and ensure access to information. It should not control the conclusions.
6. Ethiopia’s Continuing Political Crisis Cannot Be Ignored
Ethiopia’s political crisis is not simply a disagreement between competing political elites. It affects the daily lives, security, livelihoods, and future of millions of citizens.
The country has experienced devastating armed conflicts, widespread displacement, destruction of property, disruption of education, and serious allegations of abuses against civilians.
Different communities have experienced these crises in different ways. The suffering of one population should never be used to deny the suffering of another.
This is precisely why an independent national process is necessary.
For example, the continuing conflict and insecurity in parts of Oromia and Amhara require serious examination. Allegations of ethnic targeting, unlawful killings, arbitrary detention, forced displacement, and abuses by different armed actors must be investigated through impartial mechanisms.
The objective should not be to assign collective guilt to an ethnic community. Responsibility must be established based on evidence and individual or institutional conduct.
Ethiopia cannot achieve national reconciliation by creating new divisions or allowing political narratives to compete over whose suffering deserves recognition.
Every Ethiopian citizen must have equal dignity and equal protection under the law.
The national dialogue must therefore recognize the experiences of all affected populations without political favoritism or ethnic discrimination.
7. The Problem of Political Freedom and Participation
A national dialogue cannot be meaningful when the political environment does not permit free participation.
Opposition organizations must be able to organize, communicate, and present their positions without intimidation. Journalists must be able to investigate and report. Civil society organizations must be able to operate independently.
Political prisoners and individuals detained for expressing peaceful political opinions must receive due process and have access to fair judicial procedures.
The presence of opposition representatives at a government-organized conference does not automatically establish political inclusiveness.
The real measure is whether those representatives can freely express their positions, challenge the government, and help shape the agenda.
Furthermore, communities affected by conflict must have meaningful representation. Their participation should not be limited to individuals selected because they are politically acceptable to the authorities.
A dialogue that excludes important political and social constituencies cannot claim to represent the nation as a whole.
The commission must therefore demonstrate that participation is genuine, not symbolic.
8. The Need for an Independent Truth-Seeking Institution
Ethiopia needs an independent national truth-seeking mechanism with a clear mandate, legal protection, and sufficient institutional authority.
Such an institution should examine serious human rights violations across different political periods. Its work should be guided by evidence, impartiality, and respect for victims.
Its membership should reflect professional competence, public confidence, and political independence. Human rights specialists, legal experts, historians, representatives of victims, and independent civil society institutions should have meaningful roles.
The institution must also be able to collect testimony, examine documentary evidence, protect witnesses, and publish findings.
Where criminal responsibility is established, appropriate cases should be referred to independent judicial institutions.
The process must not become a political instrument for punishing opponents or protecting allies.
There should be no selective justice.
Equally important, the institution must protect witnesses and victims. People who testify about abuses must not become targets of retaliation.
Without these protections, many individuals will understandably remain silent.
9. Why Reconciliation Without Accountability Is Unsustainable
One of the greatest dangers facing Ethiopia is the temptation to confuse reconciliation with forgetting.
Reconciliation does not mean asking victims to abandon their demands for justice. It does not mean letting perpetrators off the hook simply because political leaders want to move forward.
A society cannot build lasting peace by ignoring the suffering of its citizens.
History repeatedly demonstrates that unresolved grievances can become the foundation for future political instability. When communities believe that their suffering has been ignored, resentment can deepen, and mistrust can become entrenched across generations.
Accountability is therefore not an obstacle to reconciliation. Properly implemented, it is one of its essential foundations.
At the same time, accountability must be fair and impartial. It must respect due process, the presumption of innocence, and the rights of all accused individuals.
The objective should be to establish the truth and prevent future violations, not to create another cycle of political revenge.
Ethiopia needs a process that breaks the historical pattern in which each new government condemns the previous government while avoiding an examination of its own conduct.
No government should inherit the authority to determine which historical crimes deserve attention and which should remain forgotten.
10. What Ethiopia Needs Moving Forward
For the national dialogue process to gain public confidence, several fundamental conditions must be established.
First, the commission must demonstrate institutional independence. Its leadership, procedures, and conclusions must be protected from political interference.
Second, the agenda must be determined through meaningful public consultation. It should include constitutional questions, the structure of the state, ethnic federalism, national identity, political representation, democratic governance, and the protection of individual and collective rights.
Third, all relevant political and social groups must be able to participate freely. Exclusion should not be used as a political strategy.
Fourth, the government must guarantee freedom of expression, freedom of association, access to information, and protection against political retaliation.
Fifth, Ethiopia needs an independent transitional justice process that can investigate serious historical and contemporary violations without political interference.
Sixth, the findings of independent investigations must lead to meaningful institutional reforms and appropriate legal accountability.
Finally, the international community, including relevant African Union and United Nations institutions, may provide technical assistance, monitoring, and expertise where appropriate, provided Ethiopian ownership and the process’s independence are preserved.
These conditions are not unreasonable demands. They are the minimum requirements for a credible national reconciliation process.
Conclusion: Ethiopia Needs Truth Before Reconciliation
Our concerns about the National Dialogue Commission were present from the beginning. They were based on a fundamental understanding that national reconciliation cannot be established through a process whose independence and credibility remain in question.
The South African experience under Archbishop Desmond Tutu offers an important lesson. A nation must confront its past, listen to its victims, investigate abuses, and acknowledge historical responsibility if it hopes to build a peaceful democratic future.
Ethiopia must move beyond political declarations and government-managed conferences. It needs an inclusive process that belongs to its people, not to a particular administration or political organization.
The commission should not become a mechanism to legitimize the government, protect political interests, or create the appearance of reconciliation while serious grievances remain unresolved.
The country needs an honest examination of its history, an independent investigation of alleged violations, and a political framework that guarantees equal citizenship and democratic participation.
Above all, Ethiopia must abandon the dangerous tradition in which political power determines historical truth. Governments change, political organizations rise and fall, but the suffering of ordinary citizens remains part of the nation’s history.
No political organization should have the authority to erase that history.
Our position should therefore remain clear: No genuine national reconciliation without truth, no sustainable peace without accountability, and no democratic future without political freedom and equal justice.
Ethiopia deserves a national dialogue that brings its people together, not one that protects those who hold power. The ultimate objective must be to build a country in which every citizen, regardless of ethnicity, religion, political belief, or regional background, enjoys equal dignity, security, justice, and freedom.
That is the foundation upon which a genuinely united and democratic Ethiopia can be built.
Dr. Mesfin Araya’s role
In the end, it appears that our earlier concerns about Dr. Mesfin Araya were justified. He was, in fact, a cadre, and his five years serving as a mediator seem to have accomplished precisely what he and those who placed him in that position wanted. Rather than helping create the conditions for a genuine and meaningful political settlement, his involvement ultimately raises serious questions about the purpose, independence, and credibility of his mediation.
Today, Ethiopia is on the verge of political, economic, and social collapse. The country is facing an unprecedented crisis, with escalating conflicts, deepening divisions, and a growing loss of public confidence in its political institutions. Yet, those who were supposedly entrusted with facilitating dialogue and reconciliation appear to have little left to contribute to resolving the crisis. Having completed their assignments, they seem to have returned to the political circles and government interests they were originally expected to serve.
What is particularly disappointing is that Dr. Mesfin Araya and those associated with his group appear to have undermined and derailed what was gradually taking shape as a potentially meaningful alternative. Instead of encouraging an inclusive process capable of addressing Ethiopia’s fundamental political problems, they helped weaken the emerging initiative and ultimately went their separate ways.
The central question, therefore, is not simply what Dr. Mesfin Araya accomplished during his five years as a mediator, but whose interests his mediation ultimately served. A mediator’s responsibility should be to bring opposing sides together, establish trust, and create the political space necessary for a genuine national settlement. When the process instead contributes to discrediting or dismantling an emerging alternative, it is reasonable to question whether the original mission was ever pursued in good faith.
History will ultimately judge the role these individuals played. Ethiopia did not need another political exercise that would consume years, raise expectations, and deliver little meaningful progress. It needed an independent, credible, and courageous effort to confront the country’s fundamental problems. Unfortunately, the outcome appears to have been the opposite: an opportunity lost, an emerging initiative weakened, and a country left facing an even deeper crisis.
Editor’s Note: Views in the article do not necessarily reflect the views of borkena.com
__
Join our Telegram Channel: t.me/borkena
Like borkena on Facebook
To submit a press release, send the submission to info@borkena.com
Add your business to Ethiopian Business Listing / Ethiopian Business Directory
Join the conversation. Follow us on X (formerly Twitter) @zborkena to get the latest Ethiopian news updates regularly