HomeOpinionEthiopia’s Foreign Policy at a Crossroads: Ethnic Politics, Political Patronage, and the...

Ethiopia’s Foreign Policy at a Crossroads: Ethnic Politics, Political Patronage, and the Making of “Innocents Abroad”

Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ethiopia
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Ethiopia (SM/file)

By Shanko Dache

Foreign policy is an extension of domestic policy. If a country has effective domestic policies with strong and competent institutions to protect the country’s sovereignty and national interests and to create effective international relationships, it will have a strong foreign policy. However, if a government doesn’t have strong and accountable institutions to create unity, professionalism, and national pride within the country, it will struggle to effectively represent its interests abroad.

The Ethiopian government these days is creating anxiety about its strategy in international relations. It needs to have a strong diplomatic corps to deal with the complex nature of its global relations.

But, Ethiopia has challenges to maintain a strong international representation such as nepotism, political favoritism and inadequate institutional frameworks, which limit professional credentials.

This is not merely an issue of diplomatic appointments. That is symptomatic of a larger concern about the tension between short-term domestic political goals and the long-term national interests of the country.

 Ethnic Politics vs National Interest

An important role of government is to put the interest of the nation first. As Ethiopia is a diverse country, there must be institutions that are unbiased and can represent the whole nation’s interest.

By including ethnicity when appointing individuals into positions of power in institutions, there will be no sense of professionalism, merit, and national representation. Having ethnicity within government institutions will cause a lack of trust from the public, create a more divided political atmosphere, and prevent a cohesive national strategy.

Diplomacy must be impartial and for the country’s interest. Ethiopian Diplomats are there to represent the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia and its people. They do not represent any one ethnic group, political organization or former government.

They should be representing the whole Nation. If there are any biases within the diplomatic service then they may be seen as representing the internal political interests rather than being a credible representation of the Ethiopian state.

A unified nation will give a strong and credible voice to the Government within international relations. However, if the Government allow internal political differences, ethnic disputes and institutional bias to affect the diplomatic service then these issues will inevitably begin to affect the foreign relations of the country.

Ultimately a country’s strength in diplomacy will depend upon the diplomats’ skills and the unity, credibility and integrity of the nation they are representing.

The Making of “Innocents Abroad”: Political Appointments Versus Diplomatic Competence

Recently there has been news that the Ethiopian government has appointed 32 individuals to carry out the work of diplomacy overseas. Many of whom have previously served as ex-ministers or worked for the government. Whilst they could offer valuable political experience, knowledge of how government works, and good international links, this doesn’t necessarily mean that they will have the right skillset for the diplomatic role.

Are they being appointed because of their diplomatic skills, experience, knowledge, and ability to represent Ethiopia well? Or are they being appointed based on their political connections, relationships, and previous government experience?

Members of the so-called Yemekeker Commission who promoted the OPDO agenda have been appointed as ambassadors. Ministers and commissioners who were accused by Abiy Ahmed of corruption and alcoholism, and subsequently fired have also been appointed as ambassadors. 

Abiy Ahmed has even said publicly that his government was spying on those individuals prior to firing them. This raises questions around how individuals are selected to work within the government and the political and professional standards expected from Ethiopia’s diplomatic corps. If those who were previously fired from their positions in government due to allegations made against them are now seen to be appropriate candidates to represent Ethiopia abroad, then what criteria is being used?

This makes me think of the famous book written by Mark Twain, ‘The Innocents Abroad.’ This can be used ironically to refer to individuals who enter new international situations without much knowledge.

Ethiopia is risking creating their own Innocents Abroad by appointing individuals to high-level diplomatic roles without any relevant background.

Diplomacy is a specific career and should not be seen as a retirement option. Embassy roles shouldn’t be given to individuals who have worked in government before. Diplomacy requires a vast amount of knowledge, including international law, international politics, economics, negotiation, international trade, and communication. They need to understand the political and economic situation within the countries they are representing.

Ambassadors need to be able to communicate with foreign governments, to explain and defend Ethiopia’s foreign policy, to negotiate, to attract investment, to create strategic partnerships, and to be able to intelligently deal with international situations. This includes a lot more than just being politically loyal and having experience within government.

Having ex-ministers isn’t an issue. However, using political connections and government experience over actual skill is an issue.

To ensure Ethiopia has an authentic diplomatic presence, they should be appointing individuals based on merit, transparency, and the long-term benefit of the country. Otherwise, they risk becoming part of the political patronage system

Corruption and Weak Institutions

Another issue that has become a huge problem in Ethiopia is corruption.

Public institutions are very prone to corruption, nepotism, conflict of interest, and personal gain. This can cause a lack of consumer confidence. This is especially an issue within the diplomatic department, as there may be sensitive and secretive communication.

Salaries, treatment, and conditions within the Ministry of Foreign Affairs should be taken seriously. Government officials such as diplomats should be paid fairly and be in an environment that encourages professionalism.

 A lack of salary doesn’t necessarily cause corruption, but poor conditions, lack of monitoring, and inefficiencies can cause issues.

There are concerns that government officials may be selling sensitive information to foreign governments such as Egypt. Whilst this isn’t proven, it does cause concerns over information security.

If there are any credible claims of espionage, bribery, or leaking of classified information, this should be properly and independently investigated. National security cannot be protected by accusations. They need proper institutions, secure processes, and fair application of law.

Finally, if the integrity of the diplomatic department is questionable, they won’t be respected internationally.

 Ethiopia’s Strategic Situation and the Cost of Poor Diplomacy

Ethiopia is a strategically important nation. It has a large population, economic capacity, great geographical position, and rich history, meaning it has a huge amount of influence.

However, due to its strategic importance, it is stuck in a complex web of relationships.

This means Ethiopia faces many challenges. Including lack of access to the ocean, relationships with Eritrea and Somalia, tensions with Egypt over the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam, and security and economic and geopolitical issues.

These issues cannot be dealt with through simple political statements. A coherent foreign policy is needed. We need professional diplomats, skilled negotiators, and good intelligence and understanding of international law.

 Ethiopia wanting access to the ocean requires careful diplomacy, international law, good negotiation with neighboring countries, and understanding of real security and economic concerns.

 The Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam requires a long-term approach, technical knowledge, understanding of international law, and creating positive relationships.

 A poor diplomatic service can cause simple disagreements to become unnecessary international disputes. This can cause lost opportunities to work with others and reduce foreign investment. It will also put Ethiopia at a disadvantage during negotiations.

Ethiopia cannot afford to create a foreign policy based purely on internal political factors.

 Lack of Professionalism

One of the biggest impacts of political patronage is the lack of professionalism. If individuals are being appointed due to personal connections, political alignment, or ethnicity, those with the required knowledge and professional skills will be left behind. Over time this will cause a lack of capability within institutions and discourage talented individuals from entering the industry. Diplomacy shouldn’t be any different.

An ambassador doesn’t need to be a professional diplomat. People from a variety of professional backgrounds, including academia, economics, international law, and trade, will be great diplomats as long as they have relevant qualifications, experience, knowledge, and preparation. There should be clear professional standards.

 Ambassadors should be appointed based on:

  • Knowledge of international relations/foreign affairs from an academic/professional background.
  • Experience in diplomacy, international negotiation, or similar professions.
  • Knowledge of international law, geopolitics, and regional security.
  • Language skills and knowledge of culture.
  • Integrity, political impartiality, and good professional judgment.
  • Evidence that they can help further Ethiopia’s economic, political, and strategic interests.

 Otherwise, they risk becoming another form of political favoritism.

Damage to Ethiopia’s Reputation

The reputation of a country is influenced by the quality of individuals representing it. Ambassadors often become the main contact for governments. How they deal with foreign governments, international organizations, investors, and diplomats can be influenced by their knowledge, communication, and negotiation skills.

Unprepared diplomats will cause issues with relationships, confusion around current political situations, poor negotiation, and lack of opportunities for the country.

Most importantly, poor diplomatic skills will affect the country for a longer period of time than their time in the role. International agreements, strategic partnerships, and relationships often affect the countries’ interests for many decades.

Therefore, Ethiopia needs diplomats who can clearly communicate a cohesive vision. As the government is temporary, the interest of Ethiopia remains constant

The Future: Creating a Professional Diplomatic Service

A country’s reputation internationally is largely influenced by their political leaders but also those representing them.

Ambassadors often play a key role in international relations. How they behave, what they know, and how they communicate and negotiate will affect how foreign governments, international organizations, investors, and diplomats see the country.

If the ambassador lacks knowledge, this can cause issues with relationships, confusion around politics, and poor negotiation. Meaning they will miss out on opportunities.

Most importantly, if the ambassador lacks knowledge, he or she will cause issues, which will affect the country for a lot longer than his or her time in the role. International agreements, partnerships, and relationships often affect a country’s interests for many years.

Therefore, Ethiopia needs ambassadors who can provide a clear vision and not just protect the short-term political interest of the current government. The government can change, but Ethiopia’s national interest remains.

 Conclusion: Ethiopia Needs Ambassadors

Ethiopia is at a key point in its political and diplomatic development. Without strong institutions, national unity, and a competent diplomatic force, it will not be able to take advantage of its strategic position and economic potential to increase its influence regionally and internationally.

The recent news that 32 individuals have been placed in diplomatic roles should be the start of a conversation nationally about what standards we expect from our appointments. We do not want former ministers and political figures in diplomatic roles. However, we need to ensure everyone appointed has the right level of competency, integrity, and professionalism.

We need professional diplomats who understand the world, value international relations, and can advocate for the whole country. We do not want diplomatic roles to become a reward for political loyalty, a retirement scheme, or to allow us to make space for politically connected individuals.

Ironically, Ethiopia has a long history of international relations and has played a key role in African diplomacy. We shouldn’t let political patronage and lack of professionalism create a new generation of ‘innocents abroad’.

A nation can have no foreign policy stronger than its own institutions. It can have no international reputation better than the quality, competence and integrity of the people who represent it.

We need to move away from ethnic and political patronage and focus on representing the nation as a whole. Move away from rewarding political loyalty and focus on having professionals. Move away from short-term political gain and focus on having a foreign policy based around long-term national interest.

Ultimately Ethiopian ambassadors should be working for Ethiopia and its people, not those who appointed them. This should be the starting point of our future diplomatic approach.

Editor’s Note: Views in the article do not necessarily reflect the views of borkena.com  

__

Join our Telegram Channel: t.me/borkena

Like borkena on Facebook

To submit a press release, send the submission to info@borkena.com

Add your business to Ethiopian Business Listing / Ethiopian Business Directory  

Join the conversation. Follow us on X (formerly Twitter)  @zborkena to get the latest Ethiopian news updates regularly

advertisment

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here