Ethiopia: global rights activists criticize Amnesty with #DishonestAmnesty

Rights advocacy group, Amnesty International, facing staunch criticism from Ethiopian activists over defending Oromo protest

Teshome Borago
Follow him on twitter : @MTBorago
August 16,2020

Amnesty International has come under fire from Human rights advocates and Ethiopian activists after it posted a controversial video defending #OromoProtests which has led to a cleansing of ethnic and religious minorities in the Oromia region of Ethiopia.

Using the hashtag #DishonestAmnesty, rights activists worldwide criticized Amnesty International’s East African Bureau, which ignored the recent mass killing of over 200 Ethiopians, but focused on the mass arrests of detainees accused of involvement in the gruesome crimes.

Amnesty’s video was first redistributed by human rights activist Edna Alemayehu, who is known for her work with the Solidarity Movement for New Ethiopia (SMNE). Her team went to Oromia to investigate the July mass killings and documented several personal stories of various victims who were targeted by an Oromo nationalist mob following the assassination of musician Hacalu Hundesa. Alemayehu started the #DishonestAmnesty online campaign and she said Amnesty should blame the Ethiopian government for “dereliction of duty to protect its citizens as they were being slaughtered in their homes,” not for arresting people suspected of the crimes.

Several international media have also documented an ethnic cleansing which at times also took on religious dimensions as the Orthodox Christian victims were minorities in some Muslim dominated towns of Oromia. Associated Press (AP) said mobs were “going home to home checking identity cards and targeting Amhara residents.” While Globe & Mail said the killers chanted “this is Oromo land” during the massacres. In one incident in Dera town of Oromia, Dereje Feleke said his son was “dragged outside, stabbed multiple times and finally beheaded by members of the jeering mob” due to being Amhara.

Despite many of the victims dying in the vicinity of their own homes, Amnesty International’s East Africa bureau downplayed it as an “intercommunal violence.” All other credible human rights groups, including Minority Rights Group (MRG), have called the killings an “ethnic cleansing.”

Amnesty’s regional bureau also refused to demand the Ethiopian government hold the killers of over 200 minorities accountable, but it asked for accountability for the killing of the one singer, while demanding the release of all the suspects in the mass killing.

This is not the first time Amnesty’s regional bureau came under fire, as it also downplayed the mass killings of ethnic minorities in Oromia during the October 2019 massacre. In the last three years alone, over 2 million minorities have been displaced and nearly 1200 massacred in the Oromia state, which is the center of Ethiopia’s experiment with the infamous “ethnic-federalism.” Most of the displacements from Oromia occurred near border zones of Gedeo and Somali, while the killings and property damages revolve around several suburban towns of Oromia state.

In response to criticism, Amnesty’s East Africa bureau’s staff displayed lack of professionalism as they attempted censorship and Amnesty researchers posted personal attacks on critics as well as on the Ethiopian Prime Minister.

Critics say human rights organizations like Amnesty International downplaying the sporadic ethnic cleansings in Ethiopia is dangerous because it will embolden the warlords and killers to commit more massacres regularly.



Join the conversation. Like borkena on Facebook and get Ethiopian News updates regularly. As well, you may get Ethiopia News by following us on twitter @zborkena

3 Responses to "Ethiopia: global rights activists criticize Amnesty with #DishonestAmnesty"

  1. Awash Lemma   August 17, 2020 at 7:41 am

    Time and again, AI has been deliberately fueling communal strife pretending to be defending human rights. It has always been the case that its ‘reports’ are biased, incomplete, and politically motivated, in most cases catering for the highest bidder.

    Ethiopian websites posting AI’s report are only adding in spreading its propaganda and falsehoods, and adding to the damage that may cause.

    In short, expose AI for what it is, an international click that hates the well-being of Ethiopia and its people, and therefore one strategy to refrain from posting its fictitious ‘reports’ / propaganda.

    Reply
  2. Nestant Belay   August 18, 2020 at 7:47 am

    The crime conducted against human right following the well-known assassination of Musician Hachalu Hundessa in Oromia National Regional State of Ethiopia is incited, organized, mobilized, planned, motivated and aggravated by the regional activists, managers, administration, including the regional president and security forces but they want to blame and tried to hide the truth. The situation may be seems boomed following the Hachalu’s assassination but it planned a for a while and presented both by oral and social media like Facebook, OMN, OBN, GNN, GNN, etc. during the crime many of the regional government policy participated rather than clam the problem to clean Amhara ethnic live in the region highly by giving a name Neftegna, Habesha, settlers, Milinik and Kote dude (means animals like donkey and horse).

    Reply
  3. Nestant Belay   August 18, 2020 at 7:53 am

    The crime conducted against human right following the well-known assassination of Musician Hachalu Hundessa in Oromia National Regional State of Ethiopia is incited, organized, mobilized, planned, motivated and aggravated by the regional activists, managers, administration, including the regional president and security forces but they want to blame and tried to hide the truth. The situation may be seems boomed following the Hachalu’s assassination but it planned a for a while and presented both by oral and social media like Facebook, OMN, OBN, GNN, GNN, etc. during the crime many of the regional government policy participated rather than clam the problem to clean Amhara ethnic live in the region highly by giving a name Neftegna, Habesha, settlers, Milinik and Kote dude (means animals like donkey and horse). Therefore, it is kindly requested and ask the world community, the neutral body shall have to investigate the conducted crime rather than the organization by the Ethiopian government

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.