By Jamal Altar
During a visit to Egypt on September 7, 2021, Burundi’s FM Albert Shingiro said access to water to Egypt should come before the right to development for Ethiopia. If this idea prevails, no country, including Sudan, cannot touch the Nile without Egyptian approval. While FM Albert is selling out to Egypt, Ethiopia has no intention or plans to deny or decrease access to water to Egypt or Sudan.
Egyptian problem is not diminishing water from the Nile because of the Ethiopian dam but losing its hegemony and dominance of the region and future development. It wants to build 37 smart cities and build a half-trillion-dollar project on the edge of the Sinai with Saudi Arabia; all depend on water from the Nile. Egypt is hoodwinking both Sudan and Saudi Arabia by claiming that their future hangs in the balance if Ethiopia completes the dam. A big lie. Sudan and Saudi Arabia are a victim of Egyptian machination.
Egypt is spending over $70 billion to build smart and environmentally friendly cities to transform its economy and to reduce congestion in Cairo. General Al Sisi has been all over to attract more investors, including making six trips to China and other countries. One of the costs to this cozy relationship with China is the forced deportation of Uyghurs’ political dissidents. One of the cities completed is located 45km east of Cairo, and it will become Egypt’s New Administrative Capital. It has already played host to several glitzy events and has the highest tower in Africa. Of course, the Problem is Egypt’s desire to have absolute control and monopoly on the flow of water from the Nile and one of the reasons opposing Ethiopia’s ability to tap into the Nile or build any projects, including hydroelectric dams. Egypt-building-37-new-smart-cities (https://www.theafricareport.com/127526/egypt-major-building-boom-breaths-life-into-37-new-smart-citiy-projects/)
Egypt’s problem is not Water but future development and Hegemony.
The current Ethiopian dam, GERD, will not materially or at no level will affect Egyptian water supply except during the filling period for which Egypt has adequate reserves. The issue is future development for Egypt and its hegemony in the region. Like Ethiopia, Egypt has future development plans, and it wants to broadcast to the people of Egypt and Sudan that the dam will be an obstacle.
Egypt Hoodwinking Sudan and Saudi Arabia about the Ethiopian dam
Saudi investment in Egypt is deep: Click to read: Saudi Investment (https://www.arabnews.com/node/1259251/saudi-arabia) . In addition, in the Sinai, in cooperation with Saudi Arabia, there is over a half a trillion-dollar project called NEOM: Mega Project (https://www.reuters.com/article/us-saudi-economy-city/saudis-set-500-billion-plan-to-develop-border-region-with-jordan-egypt-idUSKBN1CT154). Similarly, UAE and Kuwait have been significant investors in Egypt, and Israel is in the wing for future projects. Saudi investment in Egypt stands over $27 billion and is the second-largest investor in Egypt: 2nd-largest-investor-in-Egypt(https://egyptindependent.com/saudi-arabia-is-2nd-largest-investor-in-egypt-minister/). Besides pledging to increase its investment in Egypt, Saudi Arabia’s mega project of $500 billion bordering Jordan and Egypt will rely on getting water from the Nile River.
Sudan is the biggest beneficiary.
Sudan is the biggest beneficiary, but Egypt bought the generals, and they are doing its bidding instead of serving the needs of the Sudanese people. Besides helping to reduce flooding, Sudan will have a stable water source to develop its vast agriculture capacity once the dam is complete.
Egypt is falsely telling Saudi Arabia, Israel, and other Arab countries with investment and ties with Egypt that all bets are off the table if Ethiopia builds its hydroelectric dam that churns water instead of keeping any of it.
Consequently, Saudi Arabia is hell-bent on stopping this dam by any means necessary, including buying up Sudanese generals, supporting TPLF and financing Egyptian diplomatic strangulation of Ethiopia, expelling domestic workers, women, and children of Ethiopian origin from Saudi Arabia in retaliation.
Thus Egypt’s Problem is not the absence of or loss of water, its future economic development with the support of primarily with Saudi Arabia secondarily other states such as Israel using the Nile. Egypt has convinced Saudi Arabia and Israel that Ethiopia’s dam impedes those megaprojects. This fear-mongering enabled Egypt to align some countries squarely behind, especially Saudi Arabia, wrongly. Of course, the GERD will not materially affect these projects. Still, Egypt is exaggerating to force Ethiopia into an agreement that may violate Ethiopia’s sovereignty and put a barrier to future development and handicap future generations from benefiting from the Nile water.
With the urging of Egypt, Saudi Arabia is financing the TPLF offensive and expelling hundreds of thousands of innocent families and children of Ethiopian origin while allowing over 2 million Egyptians to reside and work in Saudi Arabia.
At the urging of Egypt and Saudi Arabia, Sudan is giving sanctuary and arms to TPLF and wants to provoke Ethiopia into armed conflict to stretch its military. Sudan is also funding and encouraging groups in Benishangul to sabotage the dam’s construction by killing drivers, closing roads, and other tactics.
Sudan and Egypt moved their military to the Ethiopian border and held regular military exercises to flex their muscles and threaten Ethiopia. In Ethiopia, Egypt and Saudi Arabia are financing extremist forces to thwart Ethiopia’s path to democracy and distract it from completing the Great Ethiopian Renaissance Dam. While destabilizing Ethiopia has the potential to unhinge the whole region given Ethiopia’s size and population, the world is watching with relatively benign tolerance not to antagonize two of the most powerful and dictatorial nations in the Arab world.
With Saudi Arabia’s financing, Egypt is signing a defense agreement with most of Ethiopia’s neighbors, Sudan, Kenya, Burundi, Uganda, Djibouti, and others, almost encircling Ethiopia. Some of these countries are getting hundreds of millions to sign a defense agreement with Egypt to isolate, punish, and destabilize Ethiopia. African-countries-sign-military-agreement-with-Egypt: https://newbusinessethiopia.com/politics/african-countries-sign-military-agreement-with-egypt-as-cairo-prepares-for-war/)
Saudi Arabia finances TPLF’s ability to field over 100,000 combatants with food and weapons with the urging of Egypt. Besides supporting terrorist TPLF, Saudis are financing Egyptian belligerence and diplomatic offensive at the UN and Arab League.
Why is Saudi Arabia expelling thousands of legal residents of Ethiopian origin from Saudi Arabia, funding TPLF, and throwing money to any country standing against Ethiopia? Saudi Arabia has a massive current and future investment in Egypt, including producing food using the Nile Water. The Egyptians wrongly convinced them that their investment and food supply were at risk besides their huge future investment plans.
Logically, the Ethiopian government will send a delegation to convince the Saudis otherwise and Sudan that the risk does not exist. Like its poor diplomatic relations with the USA and Europe, Ethiopia ignored both Sudan and Saudi Arabia.
So the Saudis and Sudan are lashing out. Sudan signed a defense treaty with Egypt to threaten and possibly invade Ethiopia, throwing its weight behind TPLF and other rebels in Ethiopia. The Saudis are throwing millions of petrodollars to any country willing to sign an anti-Ethiopian defense agreement with Egypt.
Sudan and Saudi Arabia are victims of Egyptian intrigue; however, this may force Ethiopia to seek new alliances with regional powers like Turkey and Iran to fend off these threats, thus forcing Ethiopia and Sudan into a bloody war.
The article is a revision of a past publication under the same title by Jamal Altar
To publish article on borkena, please send submission to email@example.com
Join the conversation. Follow us on twitter @zborkena to get latest Ethiopian News updates regularly. Like borkena on Facebook as well. To share information or for submission, send e-mail to firstname.lastname@example.org
The leader of Egypt’s fundamental problem is ONE, and only ONE.
It is very simple. The leader of Egypt want to be the MASTER of BLACK AFRICANS. Full Stop
The leader of Egypt does not have the intellect to recognize ETHIOPIA as one of the few ancient independent countries of the world with wisdom, admirable history and NOBLE sociological and anthropological make-up.
The leader of Egypt, with rigid mentality, cannot fathom the conception of Ethiopian ancient history.
The leader of Egypt is only able to see the colour of black, green, purple, white, yellow .
THAT IS ALL. and not bad for a rigid mentality with no substance.. THE END
Ethiopia and Ethiopians have to accept that they too are not totally innocent in this game of bloody politics in the Horn of Africa. Until Ethiopia faces up to its own flaws and falibility, then why should other powers believe its jingoistic leaders speeches and claims of foul play and interference by others. Ethiopia has encroached on Sudan’s territory. Yet she can’t admit her own imperfections. Ethiopia has a great deal of soul searching to do in the coming years.
Ethiopia and Ethiopians have to accept that they too are not totally innocent in this game of bloody politics in the Horn of Africa. Until Ethiopia faces up to its own flaws and falibility, then why should other powers believe its jingoistic leader’s speeches and claims of foul play and interference by others? Ethiopia has encroached on Sudan’s territory. Yet she can’t admit her own imperfections. Ethiopia has a great deal of soul searching to do in the coming years.
What a stupid piece of writing…
Egypt doesn’t need Nile Water for its Sinai.
Egyptians in KSA aren’t comparable with Ethiopians there.
Egypt would have its Nile levels below necessary if Ethiopia fills it’s dam in a short period and Ethiopia did not agree to filling it in an acceptable rate that wouldn’t cross the limits.
Egypt does not need Nile water for its Sinai, because there js a huge river in Sinai !!!!!!!!! and savera lakes.!!!
Egyptians in KSA are Arabs. not compareable to Ethio. Because Egypt havbe been a colony for over 2000 years, Nubians, Persians, Greeks, Romans, Ottomans, and British. and KSA, a former colony. Ethiopia is different.
Ethiopia decides,how long it takes to, fill the DAM. it depends how much rain will be. I MAY,MENTION THAT ETHIOPIA CAN STOP THE OVER 200 SMALL TRIBUTARIES TO THE 11 (eleven) BIG, RIVERS THAT, FEED THE BLUE NILE. WAR DOES,NOT HELP. IT IS ETHIOPIA.
Ethiopia is taking seven years to fill the dam to accommodate Egypt. Sudan is reaping the biggest benefit, but it is mislead by Egypt to think otherwise. Ethiopia is generating water with the GERD not using water for irrigation. So the claim that Egypt will suffer is a joke.
Egypt is afraid of future use not now. So looking out like Ethiopia is, therefore they have to come to a common agreement in order to address common concerns.
Egypt is bulling Ethiopia by signing military agreement and supporting terrorists like TPLF and OLF-Shane, therefore Ethiopia may not have any reason to accommodate Egypt if they don’t stop this mischief and nefarious behavior.
A misreading to quell the fears of neighboring countries about the dangers of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam.
Egypt and Sudan insist on providing them with information before filling the hydroelectric dam with water, but Ethiopia considers this a violation of its sovereignty rather than seeking to allay the fears of its neighbors.
In this article, there is a clear threat to other neighboring countries that Ethiopia will recruit fighters with the Houthi rebel group, which turned against the legitimate Yemeni government.
I think that Ethiopia’s choices would be wrong if it intervened in the Yemeni civil war.
H A M,
Ethiopia did inform Sudan and Egypt. The demand from Egypt is the operation. as if they want to be involved. That is violation of its, Ethiopias sovererinity.
YEMEN, an eye for an eye. KSA better be careful.